Brouwer: Guitar Concertos 3 and 4

On this CD:

1. Concerto for guitar & orchestra, No 3 ("Concierto elegiaco")
Composed by Leo Brouwer
Performed by Ricardo Cobo, Kiev Pro Musica
Conducted by Richard Kapp

2. Concerto for guitar & orchestra, No 4 "Concerto de Toronto"
Composed by Leo Brouwer
Performed by Ricardo Cobo, Kiev Pro Musica
Conducted by Richard Kapp

Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com
The solo works of Cuban guitarist-composer Leo Brouwer are adventurous music, filled with imagination and ingenious treatment of the instrument. These concertos show a drastically different approach to the instrument and to the art of music; they are very mild-mannered, emotionally and musically conservative pieces which sound like superior pops concert music. If that's what you like, you'll find this CD an entertaining way to pass an hour, and it's more vividly recorded than the RCA version of No. 3 played by Julian Bream and conducted by the composer. Just don't expect the Brouwer of L'espiral eternel or his other solo guitar music. --Leslie Gerber

Brouwer: Guitar Concertos 3 and 4, Music, Leo Brouwer, Richard Kapp, Kiev Pro Musica, Ricardo Cobo, Classical Music, Concerto, Contemporary Instrumental, Guitar Concerto, New Acoustic, New Age / Meditation, Pop
Leo Brouwer: Guitar Concertos Nos. 3 & 4
Average customer rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars
  • Not my first choice for these great works, but still adequate at low $$
  • Recording Quality, Disappointing - Performance, Very Good
  • Cobo is a revelation
Leo Brouwer: Guitar Concertos Nos. 3 & 4

Manufacturer: Essay
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

GeneralGeneral | Concertos | Forms & Genres | Classical | Styles | Music
GuitarGuitar | Strings | Instruments | Classical | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Classical | Styles | Music
MeditationMeditation | New Age | Styles | Music
ASIN: B00000083O
Release Date: 1995-07-18

Tracks:

  1. Concerto Elegiaco (No.3): 1. Tranquillo
  2. Concerto Elegiaco (No.3): 2. Interlude
  3. Concerto Elegiaco (No.3): 3. Finale (Toccata)
  4. Concerto de Toronto (No.4) (1987): 1. Moderato
  5. Concerto de Toronto (No.4) (1987): 2. Theme And Variations
  6. Concerto de Toronto (No.4) (1987): 3. Tempo Libero - Allegro

Amazon.com

The solo works of Cuban guitarist-composer Leo Brouwer are adventurous music, filled with imagination and ingenious treatment of the instrument. These concertos show a drastically different approach to the instrument and to the art of music; they are very mild-mannered, emotionally and musically conservative pieces which sound like superior pops concert music. If that's what you like, you'll find this CD an entertaining way to pass an hour, and it's more vividly recorded than the RCA version of No. 3 played by Julian Bream and conducted by the composer. Just don't expect the Brouwer of L'espiral eternel or his other solo guitar music. --Leslie Gerber

Customer Reviews:

3 out of 5 stars Not my first choice for these great works, but still adequate at low $$.......2007-04-21

I thought the sound quality of this recording was acceptable, but the playing was a little too "safe." Concerto Elegiaco was composed for Julian Bream, and his recording has Leo Brouwer conducting the RCA Victor Chamber Orchestra. In spite of it's lower audio quality and live performance flubs (which kind of make it even more appealing to me), the sensitivity of the Bream preformance is much more enlightening to me. Concerto de Toronto was composed for John Williams. This Ricardo Cobo cd is okay if you can pick it up for $5-7. Otherwise, get the Bream and Williams editions if anything for the authenticity. Oh yeah, I almost forgot: the cover art for this cd is lame.

2 out of 5 stars Recording Quality, Disappointing - Performance, Very Good.......2004-05-28

I'm glad these rarely heard Brouwer guitar concertos have been recorded. Currently, Concert Elegiaco has only 2 other recordings available; one by Sergio Puccini on the Klavier Label (KCD-11093 ASIN: B00000G3W5) and one by the dedicatee, Julian Bream on RCA. The Concerto de Toronto only has one other recording available by the dedicatee, John Williams on Sony #63173 (ASIN: B0000062E6).

Let's start with the Concerto Elegiaco. I have not heard the Julian Bream recording but I have heard the Sergio Puccini's recording on the Klavier label. Both performances are very good. Cobo is a little bit more polished than Puccini, but both are very good. My major compliant is with the quality of the ESSAY recording, which lacks detail and intimacy. These guitar concertos were composed for small orchestra and require a more intimate recording with there colorful instrumentation including marimba. The Klavier recording is warm, intimate and detailed with all instruments clearly audible which makes it very easy on the ears and satisfying . Even though the performance on the ESSAY label was a little better it was not satisfying because of the below average recording. Too bad, Ricardo Cobo and Brouwer deserve better.

The Concerto de Toronto is a more interesting concerto in my opinion but is again plagued by below average recording quality. The Concerto de Toronto preformed by John Williams on Sony is a better performance and a much better recording.

In the end I recommend that you get the Williams and Puccini recordings over this one. I have to give this recording a 2 star rating for recorded quality and 4 stars for performance which comes out to 3 stars overall.

5 out of 5 stars Cobo is a revelation.......2000-03-01

I think Ricardo Cobo is THE best Brouwer performer in the world. Technically great, but what feeling in his play. It is a joy to listen to him. As for the Brouwer compositions. I love them. Especially the Interlude from Concerto Elegiaco which has a a lot of elements of Etude Simple No. XVII. This is a great CD. A must for a all Brouwer, and now Cobo, fans!

Music Review:

  1. Bruckner, Anton
  2. Bruckner: Mass in F Minor
  3. Carillon Music
  4. Där blåser tre vindar på haven: Songs by Evert Taube
  5. Danzi: Wind Quintets Op. 68
  6. Dear Rogue
  7. Donizetti - Mary Stuart / Dame Janet Baker · Plowright · Rendall · Tomlinson · Opie · ENO · Sir Charles Mackerras
  8. Fayrfax: Missa Regali ex Progenie; Magnificqat
  9. German 17th Century Church Music
  10. Gewandhaus-Quartett

Music Review

music review

Music Review

Deconstructing Ghosts

Joan of Arc: Musical Revelations

Music Review: 19 Polish Songs

Major & Minor: Learn to Improvise

Kim Possible [Enhanced] [Soundtrack] [Extra tracks]

Mexican Music: 20 de Coleccion

Fleetwood Mac: Greatest Hits

Life Model

In [Import]

King of the Ragtime Writers

James Cafe

En Vivo [Live]

I Love Hip Hop V.2 [Import]

Franz Liszt: Hungarian Rhapsodies For Orchestra

Workingman's Dead