| 1. Scherzo No.1 Op.20 |
| 2. Scherzo No.2 Op.31 |
| 3. Scherzo No.3 Op.39 |
| 4. Scherzo No.4 Op.54 |
| 5. Polonaise In A Major Op. 40 |
| 6. Nocturne In E Flat Major Op.9 No.2 |
| 7. Nocturne In F Sharp Major Op.15 No.2 |
| 8. Waltz In E Flat Major O.18 No.1 |
| 9. Waltz In A Mainor Op.34 No.2 |
| 10. Waltz In D Flat Major Op.64 No.1 |
| 11. Berceuse In D Flat Major Op.57 |
| 12. Impromptu In A Flat Major Op.29 |
| 13. Impromptu Fantasie In C Sharp Minor Op.66 |
Product Description
After Two Highly Praised Recordings on Deutsche Gramophon, Gianluca Cascioli Releases an Album of Chopin.
4 Scherzi,Gianluca Cascioli,Universal,Classical
Average customer rating:
|
Chopin: Scherzi/Impromptus
Manufacturer: Deutsche Grammophon ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B0002SZVUO Release Date: 2005-01-11 |
Tracks:
- Scherzo No.1 In B Minor, Op.20
- Scherzo No.2 In B Flat Minor, Op.31
- Scherzo No.3 In C Sharp Minor, Op.39
- Scherzo No.4 In E Major, Op.54
- Impromptu No.1 In A Flat Major, Op.29
- Impromptu No.2 In F Sharp Major, Op.36
- Impromptu No.3 In G Flat Major, Op.51
Amazon.com
Yundi Li is being groomed for superstardom. He's got the looks, youth, and keyboard athleticism to fill that role, but on the basis of this all-Chopin disc (and his previous Chopin and Liszt recitals), he still lacks the interpretive maturity that translates into staying power. His B minor Scherzo, for example, comes off as excessively sectional, and its central section lacks poetry. Other works here fare better, but his attention appears focused on pianistic fluency and dazzling finger work, often at the expense of a full measure of emotional communication. The Impromptus, lovely as they are in places, tend to blandness. Li compensates for his lack of depth and spontaneity with a beautiful tone, remarkably even runs, and precise articulation at high speeds, attributes which should be sufficient for many. If you're looking for the rhetorical, probing grandeur of an Arrau or the emotional directness of a Rubinstein you'll look elsewhere. But if you're in tune with Pollini's detached, objective Chopin and enjoy hearing a skilled pianist perform impressive technical feats on the instrument, you'll want this disc. --Dan DavisCustomer Reviews:
Marketing hype?.......2006-05-30
This recording is just a finger work.
I was fortunate to listen live to the above mentioned masters many times in the past and I listened to Yundi twice in the last two years. He is certainly a great technician but he represents a new generation of pianists who opt for a technical beauty instead of delving deeper. His performance lacked of any emotional communication. He is simply not in the same league what old masters and I seriously doubt that he ever be.
It's been already six years since he won Chopin Competition and his repertoire is very limited. He travels and plays the same program over and over again. That's a danger for young artists who sign the contract with an artist management agency in early stages of their career. This young artist has certainly a great potential. I don't know who advises him but he should follow Pollini's and Zimerman's career path. After winning the Chopin Competition at the same age what Yundi Li, they disappeared for some time and reemerged much later as matured artists.
Unfortunately, in today's world young artist are subject to huge pressure which is overwhelming them. I wish Yundi very well but it is difficult to evolve as an artist while preparing your work and fitting everything into your concert schedule.
Fine Chopin Scherzi and Impromptus from Yundi Li.......2006-04-03
Agree with many music critics.......2005-06-25
Precision versus Passion: An Early Stage of a Career.......2005-06-25
But I think the young Yundi Li is pacing himself well. While he at this point does not play with the passion and the heart of the masters, he does communicate the finite details of the works of the composers he performs. To this listener's ear the passion is under the surface and will radiate when the works he is performing gel a bit longer. Being a follower of the 'true romantic pianists' these may be strong presumptions, but Li has a quality of involvement rather than detachment that seems to promise the soul of the works will follow.
It is perhaps unfair to compare Li with his contemporary Lang Lang, but both are young gifted artists and both are climbing the ladder of success. Audiences love them both even though they are polarized: Li is the cool authoritative technician while Lang Lang is the fiery passionate performance artist. And we may take our pick depending on personal preference and repertoire. For now, this CD of Lundi's Chopin Scherzi and Impromtus is a refined and elegant recording. Recommended. Grady Harp, June 05
Exquisite and Sensitive Playing.......2005-05-30
I have to say that the more I listen to this CD, the more I admire Yundi Li's impeccable technique and his fresh interpretation. His translucent, pearl-like keyboard sound in this DG fine recording make this CD tremendously enjoyable.
Wonder why, four months after the CD was released in the US, Amazon.com has not posted more editorial reviews. There are many reviews in both print and web media. I would like to paste a few here and hope they are helpful.
Listen to this radio review online:
The Arizona Republic CD of the week
http://www.kbaq.org/music/cdreviews/20050109
by Kenneth LaFave
Chicago Tribune,
John von Rhein
Published March 20, 2005
Only 18 when he won the Chopin International Piano Competition in Warsaw in 2000 (the youngest contestant ever to win the gold medal), the Chinese pianist Yundi Li dispatches this recital with a panache, poetry and musicality that mark him as a commanding Chopin interpreter.
Li has something of his own to bring to the four Scherzos. The easy brilliance of his pianism is apparent from the bravura opening of the Scherzo No. 1, with its rippling arabesques and glittering runs. The second scherzo, in which formidable chordal sequences and scales are set off by quieter, more graceful pages, evinces power and nuance that set Li apart from many of today's younger firebrands. The third and fourth scherzos are delicate, subtly complex creations; here Li's flexibility puts him fully inside the sensibility of Chopin.
The pianist acquits himself equally well in the three Impromptus, with their tricky dancelike passages and subtle contrasting themes. Let's hope Li's management lands him a recital appearance in downtown Chicago before long.
The Weekend Australian, January 22, 2005,
CLASSICAL
Murray Black
Chopin: Scherzos, Impromptus
CHOPIN was my first great love," says Chinese pianist Yundi Li -- and it shows. Of course he has the formidable technique you'd expect from a wunderkind: dazzling runs and passages, razor-sharp clarity, brilliant articulation, remarkable dynamic control. More important, though, is his warmth, intelligence and sure grasp of structure, thereby realising the individual character of each work. His scherzos are strong and supple: Li contrasts the often fiery outer sections with sensitive explorations of the melancholic middle passages. The well-paced impromptus are delicate and imaginative. Best of all is Li's cantabile and legato phrasing which, when matched with the sustained beauty of his tone, allows the music to breathe and flow. Outshining Arrau's listless octogenarian readings (Philips), Li's Chopin stands comparison with the best: Rubinstein, Pollini, Freire and Ashkenazy
NYTimes Jan. 16, 2005
Anthony Tommasini
Chopin: Scherzos, Impromptus
DEUTSCHE GRAMMOPHON has been promoting the young Chinese pianist Lang Lang to the sky. One slogan reads: "The future of classical music has arrived. His name is Lang Lang."
But Mr. Lang is not the only young Chinese pianist on Deutsche Grammophon's roster. Yundi Li won the prestigious Chopin Piano Competition in Warsaw in 2000, when he was 18. To judge from his new recording, a Chopin program offering the four scherzos and the three impromptus, Mr. Li's technique is as brilliant as Mr. Lang's but more refined, and Mr. Li is the more probing and sensitive musician.
There is plenty of white-hot virtuosity in his accounts of the scherzos. In the hell-bent opening of the Scherzo No. 1 in B minor, Mr. Li takes off in a bolt of demonic energy and doesn't let up until the somber second theme. The notes whiz by with uncanny clarity, yet Mr. Li brings out bass lines and inner voices beautifully. He uses Chopinesque rubato liberally yet tastefully. His expressive nuances are balanced by a generally cool temperament.
The overplayed Scherzo no. 2 in B flat minor sounds wonderfully fresh in his muscular, no-nonsense performance. Scurrying passagework and gossamer textures enrich his impressive account of the Scherzo No. 4 in E, though Mr. Li might profit from listening to the 1959 recording by Arthur Rubinstein, who takes time to smell the roses. Mr. Li's maturity comes through best in his tender accounts of the impromptus.
That he is a sweetly handsome young man with an appealing stage manner gives him another leg up. But I would be more reassured about his artistic depth if I saw more names of living composers (or even composers after Ravel) on his CD and recital programs. But he is already a serious and accomplished pianist. It's encouraging to know that he is making time to continue his studies in Germany
.
Average customer rating:
|
Monteverdi - Madrigali guerrieri et amorosi / Rooley, The Consort of Musicke
Claudio Monteverdi , Anthony Rooley , Emma Kirkby , Evelyn Tubb , The Consort of Musicke , Kristine Szulik, Paul Agnew, Andrew King Mary Nichols , and Alan Ewing, Allan Parkes Richard Edgar-Wilson Manufacturer: EMI Classics ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00000J2PZ Release Date: 1999-06-08 |
Tracks:
- Madrigali guerrieri: Altri canti d'Amor: Sinfonia - Altri canti d'Amor
- Madrigali guerrieri: Altri canti d'Amor: Tu Cui tessuta han di Cesare alloro
- Madrigali guerrieri: Hor che'l ciel: Hor che'l ciel, e la terra, e'l vento tace
- Madrigali guerrieri: Hor che'l ciel: Cosi sol d'una chiara fonte viva
- Madrigali guerrieri: Gira il nemico insidioso
- Madrigali guerrieri: Se vittorie si belle
- Madrigali guerrieri: Armato il cor
- Madrigali guerrieri: Ogni amante e guerrier
- Madrigali guerrieri: Ogni amante e guerrier: Io che nell'otio naqui e d'otio vissi
- Madrigali guerrieri: Ogni amante e guerrier: Ma per quel ampio Egeo spieghi le vele
- Madrigali guerrieri: Ardo, ardo, avvampo
- Madrigali guerrieri: Volgendo il ciel
- Madrigali guerrieri: Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda: Tancredi, che Clorinda un homo stima
- Madrigali guerrieri: Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda: Non schivar, non parar, non pur ritrarsi
- Madrigali guerrieri: Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda: Tre volte il cavalier la donna stringe
- Madrigali guerrieri: Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda: Torna l'ira nei cori, e li trasporta
- Madrigali guerrieri: Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda: Amico, hai vinto: io ti perdon...perdona
Tracks:
- Madrigali amorosi: Altri canti di Marte
- Madrigali amorosi: Altri canti di Marte: Due begli occhi fur l'armi
- Madrigali amorosi: Mentre vaga Angioletta
- Madrigali amorosi: Ardo e scoprir
- Madrigali amorosi: O sia tranquillo il mare
- Madrigali amorosi: Ninfa, che scalza il piede
- Madrigali amorosi: Dolcissimo uscignolo
- Madrigali amorosi: Chi vol haver felice
- Madrigali amorosi: Lamento della ninfa: Non havea Febo ancora
- Madrigali amorosi: Lamento della ninfa: Amor, dicea, il ciel
- Madrigali amorosi: Perche t'en fuggi, o Fillide
- Madrigali amorosi: Non partir ritrosetta
- Madrigali amorosi: Su, su, su, pastorelli vezzosi
- Madrigali amorosi: Vago augelletto
Amazon.com
"Madrigali guerrieri et amorosi" ("Madrigals Warlike and Amorous") is how Claudio Monteverdi titled his eighth and largest book of madrigals--which was actually two volumes in one. The "warlike madrigals" (concerned largely with the "war of love") feature the "agitated style" Monteverdi pioneered: quick, almost nervous writing, lots of rapidly repeated notes, and more syllables than a Gilbert & Sullivan patter song. These works culminate in the famous short quasi-opera Il Combattimento de Tancredi e Clorinda. The "amorous madrigals" are no less ardent, but they are less, well, warlike--that is, more leisurely paced, with plenty of chromaticism, dissonant suspensions, and giddily virtuosic runs to depict the pain and excitement of love.Anthony Rooley, Emma Kirkby, and the Consort of Musicke made these recordings in the early 1990s. While the performances were widely admired in their day, they're now universally considered (at least by those of us who actually spend time thinking about such things) to have been superseded by the remarkable work of Rinaldo Alessandrini and Concerto Italiano. It's true that some of the singing on the Consort's first disc is lackluster, but things perk right up with the young Paul Agnew's solo in Volgendo il ciel followed by an energetic Combattimento. Everyone's back in fine form for the "amorous" madrigals on the second disc; particularly notable are the virtuoso turns for Agnew, Andrew King, and Alan Ewing, as well as the Divine Miss Emma. Yes, Concerto Italiano is preferable if you can afford both of the full-price discs, but at the bargain price Virgin is charging for these reissues, you'll get more than your money's worth. --Matthew Westphal
Customer Reviews:
Mature Monteverdi at his best!.......2000-05-11
The enginnering of the recording was excellent. The only disapointment was a dearth of information about the text of the score.
Highly recommended!!
Average customer rating:
|
Chopin: Piano Works [Nocturnes - Waltzes - Ballades - Scherzi]
Fryderyk Chopin , and Tamas Vasary Manufacturer: Deutsche Grammophon ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B000065TUY Release Date: 2002-06-11 |
Customer Reviews:
Excellent.......2007-05-10
One of my favorite Chopin disks.
Magical Chopin.......2006-12-16
thankfully,.......2006-10-28
you probably have witnessed debates on whether rubinstein or pollini is the final word on chopin, whether argerich's approach stands or not.. but those debates are pointless. i think a great pianist is one who cultivates a unique voice, an individuality of tone. cortot had done this. rubinstein had done this. lipatti had done this. pollini had done this. vasary has done this. perahia has done this. and argerich has done this. the rest is up to the listener: which tone is most to your liking? some people like the demonic frenzy of argerich. some like the masculine clarity of rubinstein. i appreciate both: but vasary's tone possesses an effeminate, ethereal sparkle rivaled by only that of lipatti. sadly, lipatti lived during the monoaural age and lived to a very young age. thankfully, vasary is still very much alive: but these recordings are from the sixties.
the sound is excellent, and the performance impeccable. the ballades are unsurpassed: zimerman comes no where near, and perahia follows closely.
the famed nocturnes present an alternative to rubinstein's 1930's performances (his alter ones are mannered). his waltzes possess less of the clarity of lipatti's, but are more indulgent. this does not mean that he wears his heart out on his sleeve. his chopin, unlike that of zimerman's, cortot's, or horowitz's, bears suffering and melancholy with dignity.
like i said, it's up to personal taste. but seldom have i seen people to whom vasary did not represent the epitome of elegant chopin.
Missing a nocturne.......2006-05-21
THE FINEST SET OF NOCTURNES, WALTZES, ETC........2005-09-29
Vasary's timing and articulation are simply superb: he has a real insight into Chopin's ethos and telos: he renders the inner voicing exquisitely. Vasary's realizations suggest to me what Glenn Gould's Chopin might have sounded like had he played the Nocturnes, Ballades, Waltzes, etc.
The sound is crystal clear; the set a bargan price.
Average customer rating:
|
The Emma Kirkby Collection
Claudio Monteverdi , George Frideric Handel , Johann Sebastian Bach , Sigismondo D'India , John Dowland , Guillaume de Machaut , Hildegard of Bingen , Thomas Campion , Henry Lawes , Henry Purcell , Michael East , The Consort of Musicke , Taverner Consort Players , Roy Goodman , Anthony Rooley , Emma Kirkby , Christopher Page , Denys Darlow , Andrew Parrott , Parley of Instruments , London Handel Orchestra , Gothic Voices , David Reichenberg , and Instrumental Ensemble Manufacturer: Hyperion UK ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B000002ZJG Release Date: 1993-11-12 |
Tracks:
- Confiterbor tibi, Domine (Psalm 110)
- Now Hath Flora Robbed Her Bowers
- Stript Of Their Green Our groves Appear
- Voglio di vita uscir
- Piangono al pianger mio
- Flow Not So Fast, Ye Fountains
- Foy Porter
- Columba aspexit
- Sheep May Safely Graze
- Time Stands Still
- Diana
- Quel squardo sdegnosetto
- Maledetto sia l'aspetto
- The Lark
- Move Now With Measured Sound
- Sharp Thorns Despising
- Sich tiben im Lieben
- You Meaner Beauties Of The Night
Customer Reviews:
Interesting music interestingly sung.......2007-02-01
Some comments on works randomly selected.
Monteverdi's "Confitebor tibi, Domine." Here, Kirkby displays a clean light voice. She exhibits a spirited "Gloria Patri" with some spare but interesting ornamentation.
Campion's "Now hath Flora robbed her bowers." This cut shows off to good effect the agility in her voice.
John Dowland, "Flow not so fast, ye fountains." Here is displayed her smooth voice; her singing flows smoothly from one note to the next. There is a poignancy in her singing on this piece.
Guillaume de Machaut, "Foy porter." She treats the redoubtable de Machaut well; his works are some of the best of his time. This is smoothly song and does his work justice.
Hildegarde of Birgen, "Columba aspexit." This is the oldest composition on this CD by far. The work is spare, but well sung. There is a hypnotic quality to the work and Kirkby sings it well.
Lawes, "The Lark." Again, nice agility of her voice is displayed.
Other compositions on this CD are by Purcell, J. S. Bach, Sigismondo d'India, and Handel.
All in all, a nice sampling of the work of Emma Kirkby. I was not much familiar with her work before listening to this CD, but I am delighted that I did purchase this work.
The marriage of skill and magic.......2007-01-12
There is no such thing as too much Emma Kirkby.......2002-07-16
Well, this disk gives us 18 selections from a number of different composers from the Baroque. Every one of them is a treasure and has its own charms. I can't pick a favorite, but I can say that each of these pieces show off her voice and singing style in different ways.
Yes, I wish she had included more Purcell and something even nicer than what we have on track 3, but what would I give up? Well, that is where I say we need this to have been a two or three disk collection.
You won't go wrong with this wonderful disk!
emma's pure and magical voice........2000-10-16
Voice of an Angel!.......1999-07-20
Average customer rating:
|
Sonate Al Pizzico
Manufacturer: Atma Classique ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B000231UD6 Release Date: 2004-05-04 |
Customer Reviews:
Magic gondola ride.......2005-06-15
The music comes from a time, the early 17th century, when new genres were emerging in Italy, like the opera, oratorio, monodic song and instrumental toccata. It was a time of change and the arpa doppia, the chitarrone and the chitarra spagnola were right in the thick of things. The triple harp flourished in Naples and Florence, especially through the works of Mayone and Trabaci. The designation "arpa doppia" however first appears in Monteverdi's opera "L'Orfeo" of 1607. The Florentine "Intermedi" for the Medici wedding of 1589 include the arpa doppia and the newly developed chitarrone, a large lute with extra bass strings. Kapsberger was one of the first virtuosi to write for the chitarrone (also known as a theorbo). The 5-course Spanish guitar emerged in Spain in the late 16th century, becoming popular in Italy through the virtuoso playing and compositions of Francesco Corbetta.
This charming, elegant music testifies to the magnificence of that era. The confidence and fluency exhibited by Eilander and Stubbs tops off the allurement, and the recording is bright and detailed. Thoroughly enjoyable.
Average customer rating:
|
Chopin: 4 Scherzi/Berceuse/Barcarolle
Manufacturer: Deutsche Grammophon ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B000001GEJ Release Date: 1992-02-11 |
Tracks:
- Scherzo No. 1 In B Minor, Op. 20
- Scherzo No. 2 In B Flat Minor, Op. 31
- Scherzo No. 3 In C Sharp Minor, Op. 39
- Scherzo No. 4 In E Major, Op. 54
- Berceuse In D Flat Major, Op. 57
- Barcarolle In F Sharp Major, Op. 60
Customer Reviews:
Maybe ok for Pollini fans..........2003-11-21
powerful, poetic and everything in between.......2001-10-22
Bravo! You'll never hear these great pieces played better!.......1998-10-20
Average customer rating:
|
Chopin: 4 Ballades, 4 Scherzi / Ashkenazy
Manufacturer: Decca ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B000026D2Q Release Date: 2000-04-11 |
Tracks:
- Ballade No. 1 In G Minor, Op. 23
- Ballade No. 2 In F Major, Op. 38
- Ballade No. 3 In A Flat Major, Op. 47
- Ballade No. 4 In F Minor, Op. 52
- Prelude In C Sharp Minor, Op. 45
- Scherzo No. 1 In B Minor, Op. 20
- Scherzo No. 2 In B Flat Minor, Op. 31
- Scherzo No. 3 In C Sharp Minor, Op. 39
- Scherzo No. 4 In E Major, Op. 54
Amazon.com
Listening to these superb transfers of Ashkenazy's first complete cycles of the Ballades and Scherzos, which were recorded in the mid-1960s and have been out of the catalog for more than 20 years, is a startling reminder of why the Russian, then only in his 20s, became the dominant Chopin interpreter of his generation. While Ashkenazy's interpretive style had been anticipated by players such as Dinu Lipatti and Solomon, no one else had ever played so much Chopin with such selflessness. This is not to say that Ashkenazy's Chopin was bland, but that it eschewed histrionics and personal idiosyncrasies while missing none of the passion or emotional content of the music. His use of understatement in the G Minor Ballade brings the listener inside the work as more theatrical performances do not. In the F Minor Ballade, he creates an aura of mystery from the opening notes, sustains the labyrinthine narrative line with intensity and intimacy, and concludes with a passionate conquest of the coda. His equally inspired account of the other Ballades and all of the Scherzos make this one of the finest Chopin discs in the catalog. --Stephen WiglerCustomer Reviews:
Elegant, Understated Chopin.......2001-01-24
I'm not sure I'd recommend this as the one and only interpretation of the Ballades and Scherzos, but it's essential if you're really into these pieces and want a countervailing treatment to hold in opposition to the unbridled fury of Zimerman's rendition of the Ballades, or Pollini's blisteringly intense treatment of the Scherzos (ditto for Pollini's Ballades for that matter). At this very generous price it's luxury you can afford, and I don't think there's another recording of both the Scherzos and Ballades on one disc, with such a masterful pianist playing them.
Brilliant!..........!.......2000-07-03
As with all Chopin played at this level, there is a certain amount of interpretation. But, with Ashkenazy, it is never showy, always intelligent and insightful, reminding us more of Chopin than the player himself.
Average customer rating:
|
Chopin: 4 Scherzi; Polonaise No. 6; Ballade No. 3; Berceuse [United Kingdom]
Nelson Freire Manufacturer: Apex ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00021SUGS Release Date: 2006-04-14 |
Tracks:
- Scherzo No.1 In B Minor, Op.20
- Scherzo No.2 In B Flat Minor, Op.31
- Scherzo No.3 In C Sharp Minor, Op.39
- Scherzo No.4 In E Major, Op.54
- Polonaise No.6 In A Flat Major, Op.53
- Ballade No.3 In A Flat Major, Op.47
- Berceuse In D Flat Major, Op.57
- Prelude In C Sharp Minor, Op.45
- 3 Ecossaises, Op.72 No.3
Customer Reviews:
Pianist with the finest technical dexterity but also with the heart and soul of a poet.......2007-07-24
If you like Chopin, try these!
Average customer rating:
|
Chopin: Scherzi and Impromptus; Allegro de concert
Manufacturer: Naxos ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00000J8XX Release Date: 1999-09-28 |
Tracks:
- Scherzo No.1 in b, Op.20
- Scherzo No.2 in b flat, Op.31
- Scherzo No.3 in c#, Op.39
- Scherzo No.4 in E, Op.54
- Impromptu No.1 in A flat, Op.29
- Impromptu No.2 in F#, Op.36
- Impromptu No.3 in G flat, Op.51
- Impromptu No.4 in c#, Op.66, 'Fant-Impromptu'
- Allegro De Concert, Op.46
Customer Reviews:
Fabulous impromptus but something's lacking in the Scherzi.......2007-03-15
Biret is stellar in the central lyrical interlude of the first Scherzo. But in the scherzo theme itself, she plays slow and with a disconnected phrasing: there are too many starts and stops without any legato. Even in the virtuosic ending, all her technical precision means nothing when she's not even engrossed in the passion of the music. I've heard so many bad renditions of the second Scherzo, but Biret actually does a fine job in this one. With the delicacy of a kitten's paw and the violence of a panther's claw, she demonstrates dynamic control in the central section, and a satisfying sonority in the scherzo theme. Unfortunately, she fails to deliver in the third Scherzo. She is above-average in the poetic central section, but she is completely inadequate in the framing scherzo theme. Towards the end she builds up some steam only to fail to make a cohesive stream out of the passagework. The fourth Scherzo is not that bad. Biret really delves into Chopin's pathos of the middle part; overall, she seems more inspired in this performance.
For some reason, Biret truly shines in the Impromptus. Her suave interpretation of the first Impromptu's opening theme and her ethereal articulation of Chopin's melancholy musings are distinctive. In the second Impromptu, Biret's delivery is a triumph. From the fragile opening to the booming crescendo of the march-like theme toward the middle, Biret displays top-notch poise and strength. The third Impromptu is almost as good as it gets: Biret's delectable phrasing and rubato definitely does justice to Chopin's angelic music. The Fantasie-Impromptu is not as special, but I've heard so many eminent pianists play this, that it's hard for Biret to match them. I think her greatest weakness is in the fast barnstorming moments; her manifestation of Chopin's sorrow in the slower bars is immaculate, though.
Last, but unquestionably not the least, is Chopin's sublime Allegro de concert Op. 46. I think Biret makes up for her inconsistencies and empty emotions in the Scherzi with her lovely realization of this piece. This lengthy but absolutely beautiful work is given the best treatment in Biret's hands. Biret's arsenal includes a full-blooded attack and a melting lyricism. She has completely regained that rich legato and warmth that was lacking in the Scherzi. In my estimation, this is the best piece on here, a breathtaking and often disregarded Chopin work.
Bottom line: For those interested in a superlative display of technical power and musicality in the Scherzi, look elsewhere. However, don't let that deter you from sampling her spellbinding interpretations of the Impromptus and the Allegro de concert.
Average customer rating:
|
Vivaldi Edition: Le Quattro Stagioni (with bonus CD: Portrait)
Manufacturer: Opus 111 ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00006IWQR Release Date: 2003-07-15 |
Customer Reviews:
Lives up to the reviews.......2006-03-11
that it more than lives up to them. The Concerto Italiano plays with extreme sensitivity, and with unparalleled sweetness. Everything about their handling of accents and phrases really *is* unlike others'. They tend to linger in the moment, especially the violins, and announce the beauty of moment after moment. This is definitely not for everyone, understandably, and if you are in a musical hurry, this is decidedly not the recording for you. But if you would rather sip a glass of wine than gulp a beer, I think this might just be the merlot you've been looking for.
Music Review:
- Alexander Scriabin: Complete Symphonies/Poème de l'extase, Op 54
- André Jolivet: Chamber Music
- Bach: Brandenburg Concertos No. 1-4
- Beethoven: Music for Wind Instruments
- Bela Bartok: Violin and Piano Music, Volume 3
- Billy Mayerl: The Nimbled Fingered Gentleman
- Bravo Bassoon
- Brazileira
- Bruno Canino Plays Rossini & Dinizetti
- Burrell: Landscape; Concerto for viola
Music Review
Operation Blade (Bass in the Place) [CD-single] [Import]
Soprano: Arias By Massenet, Berlioz, Lehar, Etc
Spohr: String Quintets (Complete), Vol. 4
Shuffle Town: Western Swing on King: 1946-1950 [Import]
Sweet Smell of Success: Best of the Epic Years [Import]